The news
This week, six crypto industry groups — representing the teams behind Aptos (APT), Avalanche (AVAX), Cardano (ADA), Chainlink (LINK), Hedera (HBAR), and Stellar (XLM) — filed comment letters urging the US Securities and Exchange Commission to finalize a digital-commodity rule that would place their tokens outside the securities framework. Ripple filed a separate comment letter on October 20 supporting the same effort and focused on refining token classifications. The comment period on the SEC's proposed crypto framework, introduced in August, formally closed on October 20 after drawing about 140 public comments.
The coalition's argument traces to a footnote in the SEC's March 17, 2026 guidance, which tied the six tokens to futures regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. The groups want that footnote-level suggestion converted into durable rule text — because footnotes, as the industry has learned repeatedly, do not have the legal staying power of regulations.
The push
The stakes are definitional and therefore existential. A commodity label places a token under CFTC jurisdiction — the regulator of commodity derivatives — and outside the SEC's securities framework, which drives most of the agency's enforcement activity against crypto companies. The proposed framework also contemplates exemptions for crypto offerings and a conditional safe harbor for certain tokens, plus guidance on staking and other activities tied to decentralized networks.
The comment letters are requests, not outcomes. The SEC is under no obligation to adopt the coalition's language, and the final rule could differ substantially from the proposal. Industry participants and legal scholars submitted competing views over the 60-day comment window, and the fault lines are familiar: how decentralized is decentralized enough, which activities constitute an "offering," and where staking rewards fall in the taxonomy.
Background and context
The SEC-versus-CFTC turf war over crypto is the defining regulatory saga of the industry's American chapter. The SEC's position through the early 2020s — most tokens are securities, enforced case by case — culminated in lawsuits against Binance, Coinbase, and others that created enormous legal uncertainty without settling the underlying classification question. The CFTC, meanwhile, has long asserted jurisdiction over Bitcoin and Ether derivatives as commodities, and Congress has repeatedly failed to pass comprehensive market-structure legislation drawing the line.
The August 2026 framework proposal was the SEC's attempt to end the war by negotiation rather than litigation: a comprehensive rule that would define digital commodities, create offering exemptions, and establish a safe harbor. For token issuers, a commodity designation is the single most valuable regulatory outcome available — it converts existential enforcement risk into a compliance checklist. That's why six normally competitive ecosystems filed as a coalition: the classification benefits all of them equally, and a united industry front carries more weight with the Commission than six separate pleas.
The process from here is slow by design. The SEC will review the 140 comments, draft a final rule, and face the inevitable legal challenges from whichever side loses. Comment letters filed now shape the administrative record that courts will review later — which is why Ripple's October 20 letter and the coalition's filing are substantive legal documents, not press releases.
Why it matters for founders
If you're building in crypto, the commodity-versus-security determination is the single variable that decides your legal budget, your exchange listings, and your fundraising options. A finalized digital-commodity rule with a safe harbor would let founders in the covered categories build without the Sword of Damocles of an SEC enforcement action — and the coalition's six tokens are effectively auditioning the template every other project will follow.
The tactical lesson is coalition-building. Six competing ecosystems aligned on one regulatory ask because the classification question is non-zero-sum: Cardano winning commodity status doesn't cost Chainlink anything. When your industry faces a shared regulatory threat, coordinate the comment letters, share the legal research, and file together. Regulators count organized consensus.
Why it matters for investors
For crypto investors, the final rule — expected after the SEC digests the comment record — is a binary repricing event for the six named tokens and, by extension, the broader altcoin market. Commodity status de-risks the investment thesis; a rejection or a narrow rule preserves the enforcement overhang. Position sizing should reflect that the outcome is genuinely uncertain: the SEC proposed the framework, but proposing is not finalizing.
For traditional investors watching from the sidelines, the coalition's formation is itself the signal. When the teams behind six major networks jointly lobby for the same regulatory outcome, the industry has matured past its tribal phase into coordinated political action. Regulatory clarity — whenever it arrives — is the precondition for the institutional capital that has been waiting on the sidelines.
Angeled.com connects founders with investors.
Source: FinTech Five: CFTC proposes sweeping changes to prediction market regulation — Mondaq
Read Next
Open Weights Are Not Open Business Models: Mistral Large 4 and the Licensing Trap
Courts Are Writing AI's Rules Now: Three Rulings Founders Should Read
Delhi High Court Orders 24-Hour Takedown of AI Deepfake Videos Targeting Chief Minister
EU Court Adviser Says AI Training Is Legal — but Gemini's Answers May Still Infringe Copyright
AI Regulation After the Midterms: What Founders Should Do Before the January Bills Arrive
DOJ Launches Super Intelligence Task Force to Police AI Misuse



