Recommended Articles
Legal & Policy

FTC and Eight States Sue Toast Over Hidden Fees and Subscription Traps

By Angeled · October 30, 2026 · Legal & Policy
FTC and Eight States Sue Toast Over Hidden Fees and Subscription Traps
FTC and Eight States Sue Toast Over Hidden Fees and Subscription Traps

The Federal Trade Commission and a coalition of state and local enforcers sued restaurant technology company Toast Inc. on October 29, 2026, alleging that the point-of-sale and payments provider saddled restaurants with hidden fees, unauthorized charges, unwanted add-ons, and cancellation obstacles. The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, is a lawsuit, not a court finding — the allegations have not been proven, and Toast has said it strongly disagrees with them and will fight the case.

Who sued, and what the case alleges

The plaintiffs are the FTC, the attorneys general of Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Iowa, Nebraska, Oklahoma, and Utah, and California representatives acting through the Los Angeles County Counsel and the San Francisco City Attorney. The FTC authorized the complaint by a 2–0 vote. The complaint names Toast Inc. and affiliated entities including Toast Capital LLC and Toast Processing Services LLC, and alleges violations of the FTC Act, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act (ROSCA), and related state laws.

Toast sells point-of-sale hardware, software, and payment processing to restaurants, along with financing through Toast Capital. Nearly 200,000 business locations use Toast, according to the company. The FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection director, Christopher Mufarrige, said Toast "imposed hidden fees, unauthorized charges, and subscription traps that drained the hard-earned profits of businesses just trying to serve their customers."

The fees at the center of the complaint

According to the complaint, Toast's auto-renewing subscriptions cost restaurants around $900 per month on average, depending on the number of terminals and bundled services. Regulators allege customers were enrolled in and charged for add-on services — including employee timekeeping, payroll processing, and payroll-tax filing — without their consent.

The complaint also challenges Toast's "Pay-as-you-Go" plan, which advertises hardware and software for $0 per month in exchange for higher payment-processing fees. Regulators allege the company failed to clearly disclose other costs attached to that plan, including:

  • A $150-per-month early termination fee for each remaining month of a contract
  • A requirement to return hardware or pay its full retail value if payment processing did not begin within 120 days
  • An $85 monthly payment-processing charge for restaurants that temporarily close

One customer allegedly faced a $5,318.87 early termination charge after cancelling following four years with the company. The complaint further alleges Toast added a $0.99 fee to certain online orders above $10 from September 2021 through late July 2023, without adequate disclosure to restaurants or their patrons, with the money going to Toast rather than the restaurants.

Cancellation and customer support

Cancellation is the other pillar of the case. The complaint alleges customers seeking to cancel had to provide 30 days' written notice of their "intent not to renew," a requirement regulators say was not clearly disclosed at enrollment. Customers were then routed to phone or chat teams that questioned them and pitched them to stay. Restaurants with a Toast Capital loan balance allegedly faced accelerated repayment of the entire loan if they cancelled or switched providers — effectively a choice between an unwanted subscription and an immediate loan payoff.

The complaint also alleges Toast falsely advertised "24/7/365" customer support that it did not deliver. Toast has pushed back on the legal theory, arguing that ROSCA was designed for online consumer shopping and was never meant to apply to commercial agreements between businesses. The company has said it has cooperated with the FTC's review since mid-2025.

Why it matters for founders and investors

This case is a warning shot for any company selling subscriptions to small businesses. Regulators are treating B2B subscription practices with the same scrutiny long applied to consumer subscriptions: every fee must be disclosed before purchase, add-ons need affirmative consent, and cancellation cannot be harder than signup. For founders, the practical lesson is to audit checkout flows, renewal notices, and termination clauses now — before an enforcer does it for you. For investors, subscription revenue quality matters more than ever: revenue built on hard-to-cancel contracts and undisclosed fees carries legal and reputational risk that can surface years later.

Angeled.com connects founders with investors.

U.S. Federal Trade Commission, Toast Inc. case page and press release, October 29, 2026
Law360, "FTC, States Allege Toast Trapped Restaurants With Fees," October 29, 2026
QSRweb, "FTC, states sue Toast over alleged hidden fees, subscription traps," October 29, 2026

Read Next