On October 15, 2026, US District Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein of the Southern District of New York rejected a joint motion by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and Gemini Trust Company to vacate their January 6, 2025 consent order. The $5 million civil penalty — already paid, and not returned — and the permanent injunction against Gemini remain fully in place.
The case, CFTC v. Gemini Trust Company (No. 1:22-cv-04563), began in 2022, when the CFTC sued Gemini alleging it had made false or misleading statements of material fact to agency staff during the agency's review of a proposed bitcoin futures contract. The consent order resolving the case was entered just three weeks before a scheduled trial.
The joint motion to undo it
In an unusual twist, both sides moved together to erase the judgment. On May 28, 2026, the CFTC and Gemini jointly asked the court to vacate the consent order. The Commission argued that, under its renewed enforcement priorities, it should not have filed the complaint in the first place. Gemini said it had settled under coercive regulatory pressure and wanted its record cleared.
Judge Hellerstein was unmoved. He ruled that their arguments did not warrant reopening the judgment — and so the penalty and injunction stand.
What consent orders and permanent injunctions actually mean
This is the part of the story most founders misunderstand, so it's worth spelling out.
A consent order is a court judgment entered when both sides agree to settle without a trial. Unlike a private settlement agreement, it carries the force of a court order — violating it is contempt of court, not just breach of contract. Consent orders typically include neither an admission nor a denial of the underlying allegations, but they bind the company as firmly as a litigated verdict.
A permanent injunction is a court order that restrains specified conduct indefinitely. For Gemini, it means court-supervised limits on how it may interact with the regulator and conduct certain business going forward. Permanent injunctions don't expire when agency leadership changes — they bind until a court modifies them, which almost never happens.
That's precisely why the judge's ruling matters. Courts treat finalized judgments as bedrock: the legal standard for reopening one is extraordinarily high, precisely to prevent exactly this kind of post-hoc re-litigation. Regulatory priorities are allowed to change; finalized court orders are not rewritten to match.
Why courts rarely vacate settlements
Three principles were at work here:
- Finality. The judicial system depends on judgments staying final. If parties could jointly petition to erase a settlement whenever the political winds shifted, no resolution would ever truly resolve anything.
- Judicial independence. The CFTC's argument was essentially "we don't like this case anymore under our new priorities." Courts do not let an agency's internal policy preferences override a court's entered judgment.
- No coercion finding. Gemini's claim that it settled under "coercive regulatory pressure" is an argument courts hear often and credit rarely. Settling to avoid the risk and cost of trial is, by definition, what settlements are for — it is not coercion in the legal sense.
Why it matters for founders and investors
The lesson for crypto founders is blunt: enforcement history doesn't disappear when agency priorities shift.
- Settlements are permanent infrastructure. When you settle with a regulator, you are accepting a court order that will outlive the officials who brought the case. Evaluate settlement terms on that basis — a "cheap" settlement with a permanent injunction can be more expensive than a harder fight.
- Regulatory winds change; records don't. Investors performing diligence will find consent orders long after the agency has moved on. A vacated-order hope is not a compliance strategy.
- The timing trap. This order was entered three weeks before trial — the classic moment of maximum leverage, when trial costs are imminent and settlement feels cheapest. Build litigation and regulatory-defense reserves early so you negotiate from strength, not from the courthouse steps.
Angeled.com connects founders with investors.
Sources: The Block (Oct 16), hokanews.com (Oct 16).
Read Next
Open Weights Are Not Open Business Models: Mistral Large 4 and the Licensing Trap
Courts Are Writing AI's Rules Now: Three Rulings Founders Should Read
Delhi High Court Orders 24-Hour Takedown of AI Deepfake Videos Targeting Chief Minister
EU Court Adviser Says AI Training Is Legal — but Gemini's Answers May Still Infringe Copyright
AI Regulation After the Midterms: What Founders Should Do Before the January Bills Arrive
DOJ Launches Super Intelligence Task Force to Police AI Misuse



