Recommended Articles
Legal & Policy

Reddit vs. Perplexity: A "Hot Potato" Fight Over Who Can Represent Whom

By Angeled · October 13, 2026 · Legal & Policy
Reddit vs. Perplexity: A "Hot Potato" Fight Over Who Can Represent Whom
Reddit vs. Perplexity: A "Hot Potato" Fight Over Who Can Represent Whom

In a filing in Manhattan federal court, Reddit has asked a judge to disqualify Proskauer Rose from defending Perplexity AI in Reddit's data-scraping and copyright lawsuit, arguing the firm was Reddit's own former counsel and dropped it "like a hot potato" in favor of Perplexity. Proskauer denies any conflict and says it never agreed not to represent Perplexity. Reuters reported the clash on October 12, 2026.

The underlying lawsuit

The disqualification fight is a satellite battle in a larger war. Last year, Reddit sued Perplexity — along with SerpApi LLC — alleging the AI search startup illegally scraped Reddit's forums to feed its "answer engine," the AI system that generates direct answers to user questions. Perplexity has denied the copyright infringement claims. The case is Reddit Inc v. SerpApi LLC et al, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, No. 1:25-cv-08736.

The stakes are high on both sides: if Reddit's scraping claims succeed, the damages could be enormous, and the precedent would reshape how AI companies acquire training data. Reddit has signed content-licensing deals with Google and others for AI training — it is monetizing its data corpus legitimately — and its position is essentially that Perplexity should have paid for a license rather than scraped the data.

What is the "hot potato" doctrine?

The "hot potato" is a real legal doctrine, and it is worth understanding because it comes up constantly in corporate law. In plain terms: a law firm cannot cure a conflict of interest by firing its current client in order to represent a more lucrative new one. Courts treat that as a breach of the duty of loyalty — the client who hired you first gets your loyalty, and you cannot treat them like a hot potato to be dropped when a hotter prospect appears.

Reddit's argument: Proskauer previously represented Reddit in a whistleblower matter, and that prior representation creates a conflict barring the firm from now defending the company Reddit is suing. Reddit further says Proskauer earlier vowed it would not represent Perplexity. Proskauer's counter: its work on the whistleblower matter did not create a conflict barring it from representing Perplexity now, and it denies ever promising to stay out. Reddit is represented in the disqualification fight by Reid Bolton, Matthew Ford, and William Gohl of Bartlit Beck.

Part of a much bigger wave

This case is one data point in a wave of copyright litigation targeting AI companies over their alleged use of protected content for training — suits from news publishers, authors, and image owners are working their way through courts worldwide. Two structural questions are being litigated everywhere at once:

  1. Is training on copyrighted material fair use? Courts have not settled this, and outcomes will likely vary by jurisdiction and fact pattern.
  2. Can AI companies scrape at all? Beyond copyright, scraping implicates terms-of-service violations, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, and (in the EU) database rights.

Reddit's licensing deals with Google point to where the market is heading regardless of court outcomes: licensed data pipelines, with the biggest platforms selling structured access to their content. The scraping era of AI training is giving way to a licensing era — and the price of data licenses is becoming a real line item in AI economics.

Why it matters for founders and investors

Every AI startup's data strategy is now a litigation risk assessment. Founders should internalize three lessons from this fight. First, your counsel's conflicts are your problem: if your law firm has any history with a potential adversary, diligence that relationship before you're mid-lawsuit — disqualification fights burn time and money while the merits case stalls. Second, "we scraped what's public" is no longer a defense strategy — it is a litigation posture, and investors increasingly price it as one. Third, the licensing era creates a moat for startups that build legitimate data pipelines early: proprietary or licensed data is becoming a defensible asset, while scraped-data models face both legal and reputational overhang. For investors, the Reddit-Perplexity docket is a live index of how the training-data question resolves — and its outcome will reprice every AI company's data-risk discount. Angeled.com connects founders with investors.

Read Next