Congress's CLARITY Act — the market-structure bill that was supposed to give the U.S. crypto industry a clear statutory framework — has collapsed. With the legislative path dead, the future of American crypto regulation now rests with the agencies: the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission are leading rulemaking through their own actions. CoinDesk reports industry debate over whether agency action alone can deliver the lasting stability the market needs. For crypto founders, the message is blunt: the rules of the road will be written by regulators, not legislators — and that changes everything about compliance strategy.
What the CLARITY Act was supposed to do
The CLARITY Act (Crypto Leadership and Innovation Through Regulatory Certainty and Transparency Act) was Congress's flagship effort to settle the oldest fight in American crypto policy: which digital assets are securities, which are commodities, and who regulates what. A statutory market-structure law would have drawn clean jurisdictional lines between the SEC and the CFTC, defined registration pathways for token issuers and exchanges, and given builders durable legal certainty that no single administration could easily unwind.
With the bill's collapse, none of that happened. The jurisdictional ambiguity that has dogged the industry since the 2010s remains intact.
The agency-led path: what the SEC and CFTC are doing
In the absence of legislation, both agencies are moving on their own authority:
- SEC tokenized-stock innovation exemption (September 17, 2026): The Commission issued an innovation exemption covering tokenized stocks — a green light for experimentation in bringing equity-like instruments on-chain under defined conditions.
- SEC proposed crypto custody framework (October 1, 2026): The SEC put forward a proposed framework for crypto custody, addressing how regulated entities can hold digital assets safely and in compliance.
- CFTC comment period on leveraged retail crypto trading (October 5, 2026): The Commission opened a comment period on rules governing leveraged retail crypto trading, signaling intent to formalize oversight of high-risk retail products.
Each move is individually constructive. Together, they amount to a regulatory patchwork — real progress in specific corners, but no comprehensive framework.
Why agency action is not the same as a law
This is the crux of the industry debate reported by CoinDesk. Agency rules have three structural weaknesses compared to statute:
1. Durability. Rules adopted by one SEC or CFTC can be revised or reversed by the next. A founder building on today's exemption could face a different regime after a change in administration. Legislation, by contrast, survives elections.
2. Jurisdictional limits. Agencies can only act within the authority Congress has already given them. The SEC cannot simply declare that a token is not a security, and the CFTC cannot conjure authority over spot markets Congress never granted. The gray zones the CLARITY Act would have resolved remain gray.
3. Enforcement overhang. Without clear statutory safe harbors, enforcement actions remain the de facto rulemaking tool. For startups, that means compliance guidance arrives as someone else's settlement — an expensive and backwards way to learn the rules.
Background: how crypto got here
The U.S. has never passed comprehensive crypto market-structure legislation, despite years of effort — earlier bills, including the FIT21 Act that passed the House in 2024, stalled in the Senate. Meanwhile, the EU's MiCA regulation took full effect and several Asian hubs built licensing regimes. The CLARITY Act was the latest attempt to close that gap; its failure extends an American pattern of regulatory action without legislative foundation. The agencies have adapted by becoming more builder-friendly within their existing powers, but adaptation is not architecture.
What crypto founders should do now
Treat compliance as a live process, not a one-time setup. With rules emerging through agency action, comment periods, and exemptions, the regulatory surface is moving. Assign someone — in-house or counsel — to track it continuously.
Engage with comment periods. The CFTC's October 5 comment window on leveraged retail trading is exactly the kind of venue where startups can shape rules before they harden. Regulators genuinely read substantive industry comments, and early engagement builds credibility.
Build for portability. If U.S. rules remain fragmented, the cost of relocating or dual-jurisdiction operations stays relevant. Architecture that assumes a single stable U.S. framework is a bet the current situation does not support.
Document everything. In an enforcement-led regime, your best defense is a paper trail showing good-faith compliance effort. The startups that survive regulatory ambiguity are the ones that can prove they tried.
The bottom line
The CLARITY Act's collapse is a setback for the idea that American crypto will get clean, durable rules from Congress. The SEC and CFTC are doing real work — the tokenized-stock exemption and custody framework are genuine progress — but agency action is a bridge, not a destination. Founders should plan for years of living regulation: rules that evolve, reverse, and occasionally arrive as enforcement. The teams that treat compliance as a core competency, not an afterthought, will have the advantage.
Building in crypto or fintech? Angeled.com connects founders with investors who understand regulated markets.
Read Next
Open Weights Are Not Open Business Models: Mistral Large 4 and the Licensing Trap
Courts Are Writing AI's Rules Now: Three Rulings Founders Should Read
Delhi High Court Orders 24-Hour Takedown of AI Deepfake Videos Targeting Chief Minister
EU Court Adviser Says AI Training Is Legal — but Gemini's Answers May Still Infringe Copyright
AI Regulation After the Midterms: What Founders Should Do Before the January Bills Arrive
DOJ Launches Super Intelligence Task Force to Police AI Misuse



